Mark Timok (Douglas Freeman): 1980 USA Wrestling All-American (Honorable Mention)
Mark Murray (Thomas Dale): 1985 USA Wrestling All-American (Honorable Mention)
Eric Keysar* (Douglas Freeman): 1987 USA Wrestling All-American (Honorable Mention)
Adam Britt (Atlee): 1999 USA Wrestling All-American (Honorable Mention)
Blake Roulo (Matoaca): 2011 USA Wrestling All-American; 4x NHSCA National Champion (2008-2011);Â
2x USAW Cadet/Junior Freestyle All-American (2, 3); 2x Cadet/Junior Greco All-American (4, 6)
Cody Allala (Hopewell): 2009 USAW Cadet Freestyle All-American (5th)
J.D. Gregory (Hanover): 2013 USAW Cadet Freestyle All-American (6th)
Corbin Allen (Hanover): 2014 USAW Junior Freestyle All-American (4th)
T.J. Allen (Hanover): 2014; 2015 2x USAW Cadet/Junior Greco All-American (4th, 8th); 2014 USAW Cadet Freestyle All-American (8th)
Trent Ragland (New Kent): 2016 USAW Cadet Greco All-American (3rd)
Colin Gerardi (Powhatan): 2018 USA Wrestling Academic All-American; 2018 NHSCA National Champion; 2020 U23 Freestyle All-American (8th)
Travis Ragland (New Kent): 2019 USAW Cadet Freestyle All-American (8th)
Nicholas Vafiadis (New Kent): 2019 USAW Cadet Freestyle Runner-up